|
Search -
Finance Home -
Yahoo! -
Help |
|
Quotes & Info
|
| CBEY > SEC Filings for CBEY > Form 10-Q on 1-May-2009 | All Recent SEC Filings |
1-May-2009
Quarterly Report
You should read the following discussion together with our condensed consolidated financial statements and the related notes and other financial information included elsewhere in this periodic report and our Annual Report on Form 10-K. The discussion in this periodic report contains forward-looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties, such as statements of our plans, objectives, expectations and intentions. The cautionary statements made in this report should be read as applying to all related forward-looking statements wherever they appear in this report. Our actual results could differ materially from those discussed here. In this report, Cbeyond, Inc. and its subsidiary are referred to as "we", "our", "us", the "Company" or "Cbeyond".
Overview
We provide managed IP-based communications services to our target market of small businesses in select large metropolitan areas across the United States. We provide these services through bundled packages of local and long distance voice services, broadband Internet access and mobile voice and data, together with additional applications and services, for an affordable fixed monthly fee under fixed-length contracts.
We sell three integrated packages of services, primarily delineated by the number of local voice lines, long distance minutes and T-1 connections provided to the customer. Each of our BeyondVoice packages includes local and long distance voice services, broadband Internet access and mobile voice and data plus additional value-added applications, such as email, voicemail, web hosting, secure backup and file sharing, fax-to-email, virtual private network, and other communications and IT services. Customers may also choose to add extra features or lines for an additional fee. During 2008 we began offering secure desktop services and web-based services to customers in all of our current markets.
Our voice services (other than our mobile voice services) are delivered using Voice over Internet Protocol technology, and all such services are delivered over our secure all-IP network, which we believe affords greater service flexibility and significantly lower network costs than traditional service providers using circuit-switch technologies. We offer our mobile voice and data services via our mobile virtual network operator relationship with a nationwide wireless network provider.
We sell our services primarily through a direct sales force in each market, supplemented by sales agents. These agents often have other business relationships with the customer and, in many cases, perform equipment installations for us at our customers' sites. A significant portion of our new customers are generated by referrals from existing customers and partners. We offer financial incentives to our customers and other sources for referrals, which are charged to selling expenses.
We compete primarily against ILECs and, to a lesser extent, against competitive local exchange carriers, both of which are local telephone companies. Local telephone companies do not generally have the same focus on our target market and principally concentrate on medium or large enterprises or residential customers. In addition, cable television providers have begun serving the small and medium business market with telephone service, in addition to high speed Internet access and video. To date, we have not experienced significant competition from cable television providers and do not believe that they intend to offer the breadth of services and applications that our customers purchase from us. We compete primarily based on our high-value bundled services that bring many of the same managed services to our customers that have historically been available only to large businesses, as well as based on our customer care, network reliability and operational efficiencies.
We formed Cbeyond and began the development of our network and business processes following our first significant funding in early 2000. We launched our first market early in 2001 and have since expanded operations into twelve additional markets. Our current market expansion plan is to open two to three new markets per year depending on economic conditions and to establish operations in the largest 25 U.S. markets. The following comprises the service launch date for our current markets and the anticipated launch date of our announced future markets:
Current Markets Service Launch Date
Atlanta 2 nd Quarter 2001
Dallas 4 th Quarter 2001
Denver 1 st Quarter 2002
Houston 1 st Quarter 2004
Chicago 1 st Quarter 2005
Los Angeles 1 st Quarter 2006
San Diego 1 st Quarter 2007
Detroit 3 rd Quarter 2007
San Francisco Bay Area 4 th Quarter 2007
Miami 1 st Quarter 2008
Minneapolis 2 nd Quarter 2008
Greater Washington D.C. Area 1 st Quarter 2009
Announced Market Planned Service Launch Date
Seattle 3 rd Quarter 2009
|
We focus on adjusted EBITDA as a principal indicator of the operating performance of our business. EBITDA represents net income (loss) before interest, income taxes, depreciation and amortization. We define adjusted EBITDA as net income (loss) before interest, income taxes, depreciation and amortization expenses, excluding, when applicable, non-cash share-based compensation, public offering expenses, gain or loss on disposal of property and equipment and other non-operating income or expense. In our presentation of segment financial results, adjusted EBITDA for a geographic segment does not include corporate overhead expense and other centralized operating costs. We believe that adjusted EBITDA trends are a valuable indicator of our operating segments' relative performance and of whether our operating segments are able to produce sufficient operating cash flow to fund working capital needs, to service debt obligations and to fund capital expenditures.
We believe our business approach requires significantly less capital to launch operations compared to traditional communications companies using legacy technologies. Based on our historical experience, over time, a substantial majority of our market-specific capital expenditures, such as integrated access devices installed at our customers' locations, are success-based, incurred primarily as our customer base grows. We believe the success-based nature of our capital expenditures mitigates the risk of unprofitable expansion. We have a relatively low fixed-cost component in our budgeted capital expenditures associated with each new market we enter, particularly in comparison to service providers employing time-division multiplexing, or TDM, which is a technique for transmitting multiple channels of separate data, voice and/or video signals simultaneously over a single communication medium, or circuit-switch technology, which is a switch that establishes a dedicated circuit for the entire duration of a call.
The nature of the primary components of our operating results - revenues, cost of revenue and selling, general and administrative expenses - are described below:
Revenue
The majority of our customers subscribe to our BeyondVoice I package, which
serves customers with 4-15 local voice lines, or generally 30 or fewer
employees. We sell subscriptions of BeyondVoice II to customers with 16-24 local
voice lines, or generally 31-100 employees. Our BeyondVoice III package is
typically offered to customers with 36 to 48 local voice lines, or generally
101-249 employees. Each BeyondVoice I customer receives all our services over a
dedicated broadband T-1 connection providing a maximum symmetric bandwidth of
1.5 Mbps (megabits per second). BeyondVoice II customers receive their services
over two dedicated T-1 connections offering a maximum symmetric bandwidth of 3.0
Mbps. BeyondVoice III customers receive their services over three dedicated T-1
connections offering a maximum symmetric bandwidth of 4.5 Mbps. We believe that
our customers highly value the level of symmetric bandwidth offered with our
services. As of March 31, 2009, approximately 84.0% of our customer base had
BeyondVoice I, 14.7% had BeyondVoice II and 1.3% had BeyondVoice III.
We offer customer promotions in the form of rebates and reimbursements. These rebates and reimbursements, or promotional obligations, may not ultimately be earned and claimed by customers. We refer to these unclaimed amounts as "breakage." Prior to recording breakage, our promotional obligations are recorded as a reduction of revenue at their maximum amounts due to the lack of sufficient historical experience required under generally accepted accounting principles, or GAAP, to estimate the amount that would ultimately be earned and claimed by customers. We recognize the benefit of changes to these estimated customer promotional obligations once such amounts are reasonably estimable, which periodically results in a significant change in estimate.
Average monthly revenue per customer location, or ARPU, is impacted by a variety of factors, including the distribution of customer installations during a period, the adoption by customers of applications for which incremental fees are paid, the trend toward customers signing three-year contracts at lower package prices as compared to shorter term contracts, the amount of long distance call volumes that generate overage charges above the basic amount of minutes included in customers' packages as well as additional terminating access charges and customer usage and purchase patterns. We expect ARPU to be relatively stable through the remainder of 2009. Customer revenues represented approximately 98.2% and 97.8% of total revenues for the three months ended March 31, 2009 and 2008, respectively. Access charges paid to us by other communications companies to terminate calls to our customers represented the majority of the remainder of total revenues.
Customer revenues are generated under contracts that typically run for three-year terms. Therefore, customer churn rates have an impact on projected future revenue streams. Through mid-2007, we maintained average monthly churn rates of approximately 1.0% (we define average monthly churn rate as the average of monthly churn, which is defined for a given month as the number of customer locations disconnected in that month divided by the total number of customer locations on our network at the beginning of that month). Since that time, however, we have experienced elevated churn rates that we believe are attributable primarily to the inability of certain of our customers to meet their payment obligations as a result of deteriorated economic conditions. We cannot predict the duration or magnitude of the currently deteriorated economic conditions, but we expect our monthly churn rate will continue to be more than 1.0% for at least as long as the current economic environment persists.
Cost of Revenue
Our cost of revenue represents costs directly related to the operation of our network, including payments to the local telephone companies and other communications carriers such as long distance providers and our mobile provider, for access, interconnection and transport fees for voice and Internet traffic, customer circuit installation expenses paid to the local telephone companies, fees paid to third-party providers of certain applications such as web hosting services, collocation rents and other facility costs, telecommunications-related taxes and fees and the cost of mobile handsets. The primary component of cost of revenue is the access fees paid to local telephone companies for the T-1 circuits we lease on a monthly basis to provide connectivity to our customers. These access circuits link our customers to our network equipment located in a collocation facility, which we lease from local telephone companies. The access fees for these circuits vary by state and are the primary reason for differences in cost of revenue across our markets.
As a result of the FCC's 2005 TRRO, we are required to lease circuits under special access, or retail, rates in locations that are deemed to offer competitive facilities as outlined in the FCC's regulations and interpreted by the state regulatory agencies.
Where permitted by regulation, we lease our access circuits on a wholesale basis as UNE loops or enhanced extended links (EELs) as provided for under the FCC's Telecommunications Elemental Long Run Incremental Cost rate structure. Where UNE pricing is not available, we pay special access rates, which may be significantly higher than UNE pricing. We lease loops when the customer's T-1 circuit is located where it can be connected to a local telephone company's central office where we have a collocation, and we use EELs when we do not have a central office collocation available to serve a customer's T-1 circuit. Historically, approximately half of our circuits are provisioned using loops and half using EELs, although the impact of the TRRO has reduced our usage of the T-1 transport portion of EELs and resulted in the conversion and consolidation of a majority of the previously installed T-1 transports to high capacity DS-3 transport. Our monthly expenses are significantly less when using loops rather than EELs, but loops require us to incur the capital expenditures of central office collocation equipment. We install central office collocation equipment in those central offices having the densest concentration of small businesses. We usually launch operations in a new market with several collocations and add additional collocation facilities over time as we confirm the most advantageous locations in which to deploy the equipment. We believe our discipline of leasing these T-1 access circuits on a wholesale basis rather than on the basis of special access rates from the local telephone companies is an important component of our operating cost structure.
Another significant component of our cost of revenue is the cost associated with our mobile offering. These costs, which represent our fastest growing cost of revenue, include monthly base charges or usage-based charges, depending on the type of mobile product in service, and the cost of mobile equipment sold to our customers to facilitate their use of our service. The cost of mobile equipment typically exceeds our selling price of such devices due to the competitive market place and pricing practices for mobile services. We believe these costs are offset over time by the long-term profitability of our service contracts. Primarily as a result of the loss on the sale of mobile equipment recorded in full at the time of the sale, increased volumes of mobile sales decrease our gross margin percentages, although the growth of this service offering is expected to result in greater gross profits over time.
We routinely receive telecommunication cost recoveries from various local telephone companies to adjust for prior errors in billing, including the effect of price decreases retroactively applied upon the adoption of new rates as mandated by regulatory bodies. These service credits are often the result of negotiated resolutions of bill disputes that we conduct with our vendors. We also receive payments from the local telephone companies in the form of performance penalties that are assessed by state regulatory commissions based on the local telephone companies' performance in the delivery of circuits and other services that we use in our network. Because of the many factors, as noted above, that impact the amount and timing of telecommunication cost recoveries, estimating the ultimate outcome of these situations is uncertain. Accordingly, we recognize telecommunication cost recoveries as offsets to cost of revenue when the ultimate resolution and amount are known. These items do not follow any predictable trends and often result in variances when comparing the amounts received over multiple periods.
Selling, General and Administrative Expenses
Our selling, general and administrative expenses consist of salaries and related costs for employees and other expenses related to sales and marketing, engineering, information technology, billing, regulatory, administrative, collections and legal and accounting functions. In addition, share-based compensation expense is included in selling, general and administrative expenses. Our selling, general and administrative expenses include both fixed and variable costs. Fixed selling expenses include salaries and office rents. Variable selling costs include commissions and marketing materials. Fixed general and administrative costs include the cost of staffing certain corporate overhead functions such as IT, marketing, administrative, billing and engineering, and associated costs, such as office rent, legal and accounting fees, property taxes and recruiting costs. Variable general and administrative costs include the cost of provisioning and customer activation staff, which grows with the level of installation of new customers, and the cost of customer care and technical support staff, which grows with the level of total customers on our network. As we expand into new markets, certain fixed costs are likely to increase; however, these increases are intermittent and not proportional with the growth of customers.
Reclassifications
Reclassifications have been made to the three months ended March 31, 2008 Revenue and Cost of Revenue table within Item 2 herein to aggregate backbilling expiration credits from Other cost of revenue to Telecommunications cost recoveries as well as to disaggregate Mobile cost from Other cost of revenue. Such reclassifications were made to conform to the current presentation for the three months ended March 31, 2009.
Results of Operations
Revenue and Cost of Revenue (Dollar amounts in thousands, except ARPU)
For the Three Months Ended
March 31, 2009 March 31, 2008 Change from Previous Period
% of % of
Dollars Revenue Dollars Revenue Dollars Percent
Revenue:
Customer revenue $ 96,472 98.2 % $ 78,738 97.8 % $ 17,734 22.5 %
Terminating access revenue 1,788 1.8 % 1,755 2.2 % 33 1.9 %
Total revenue 98,260 80,493 17,767 22.1 %
Cost of revenue (exclusive of
depreciation and amortization):
Circuit access fees 12,658 12.9 % 10,573 13.1 % 2,085 19.7 %
Other cost of revenue 11,883 12.1 % 10,349 12.9 % 1,534 14.8 %
Mobile cost 8,123 8.3 % 5,657 7.0 % 2,466 43.6 %
Telecommunications cost recoveries (785 ) (0.8 )% (1,541 ) (1.9 )% 756 (49.1 )%
Total cost of revenue 31,879 32.4 % 25,038 31.1 % 6,841 27.3 %
Gross margin (exclusive of
depreciation and amortization): $ 66,381 67.6 % $ 55,455 68.9 % $ 10,926 19.7 %
Customer data:
Customer locations at period end 44,342 36,674 7,668 20.9 %
ARPU $ 755 $ 748 $ 7 0.9 %
Average monthly churn rate 1.5 % 1.3 %
|
Revenue. Total revenue increased for the three months ended March 31, 2009 compared to the three months ended March 31, 2008 primarily in proportion to the increase in the average number of customers quarter over quarter. ARPU was $755 and $748 for the three months ended March 31, 2009 and 2008, respectively. This increase in ARPU resulted from an increase in the average applications used per customer to 7.1 in the period ended March 31, 2009 from 6.4 in the period ended March 31, 2008, and the recognition of reductions to promotional obligations of $0.6 million in the three months ended March 31, 2009 related to certain customer promotional liabilities recorded in prior periods. The ARPU for the three months ended March 31, 2009 includes $5 related to the aforementioned customer promotional liabilities. We anticipate ARPU to continue to be relatively stable in future periods based on the expectation that our customers will continue to increase the average number of applications they use.
Revenues from access charges paid to us by other communications companies to terminate calls to our customers have slightly increased for the three month comparison periods due to our customer growth. These terminating access charges have historically grown at a slower rate than our customer base due to our customers' increased use of mobile services and reductions in access rates on interstate calls as mandated by the FCC. These rate reductions are expected to continue in the future, so we expect terminating access revenue will continue to grow at a rate slower than our customer growth.
The following comprises the segment contributions to the increase in revenue in the three months ended March 31, 2009 as compared to the three and nine months ended March 31, 2008:
(Dollar amounts in thousands)
For the Three Months Ended
March 31, 2009 March 31, 2008 Change from Previous Period
% of % of
Dollars Revenue Dollars Revenue Dollars Percent
Atlanta $ 21,107 21.5 % $ 19,412 24.1 % $ 1,695 8.7 %
Dallas 18,446 18.8 % 16,607 20.6 % 1,839 11.1 %
Denver 18,178 18.5 % 17,155 21.3 % 1,023 6.0 %
Houston 12,344 12.6 % 11,069 13.8 % 1,275 11.5 %
Chicago 9,653 9.8 % 8,406 10.4 % 1,247 14.8 %
Los Angeles 7,920 8.1 % 4,945 6.1 % 2,975 60.2 %
San Diego 4,084 4.2 % 1,796 2.2 % 2,288 127.4 %
Detroit 2,054 2.1 % 851 1.1 % 1,203 141.4 %
San Francisco Bay Area 2,380 2.4 % 239 0.3 % 2,141 895.8 %
Miami 1,432 1.5 % 13 0.0 % 1,419 nm
Minneapolis 645 0.7 % - nm 645 nm
Greater Washington, D.C. Area 17 0.0 % - nm 17 nm
Total Revenue $ 98,260 $ 80,493 $ 17,767
|
Cost of Revenue. The principal driver of the increase in cost of revenue is customer growth. In addition, between 2009 and 2008, we experienced an increase in both the number of mobile handsets sold and the related mobile service costs. These mobile related increases grew at a higher rate than our overall customer growth due to a higher proportion of our customers receiving our mobile services in 2009 than in 2008, driven by both the successful marketing of our BeyondMobile service to our existing customer base and a high mobile adoption rate for new customers.
Circuit access fees, or line charges, represent the largest single component of cost of revenue. These costs primarily relate to our lease of T-1 circuits connecting our equipment at network points of collocation to our equipment located at our customers' premises. The increase in circuit access fees is correlated to the increase in the number of customers; however, these increased costs are offset by savings related to our ongoing network optimization efforts, which primarily consist of transitioning to higher capacity circuits to gain efficiency in the delivery of service.
Mobile-related costs represent the second largest and fastest growing component of cost of revenue due to the high rate of adoption among our customers. These costs include monthly recurring base charges or usage-based charges, depending on the type of mobile product in service, and the cost of mobile equipment sold to our customers to facilitate their use of our service. These increased monthly recurring mobile service costs have been partially offset by declining per unit rates charged to us by our underlying mobile network provider due to our growing scale and volumes.
The other principal components of cost of revenue include long distance charges, installation costs to connect new circuits, the cost of transport circuits between network points of presence, the cost of local interconnection with the local telephone companies' networks, internet access costs, the cost of third-party applications we provide to our customers, access costs paid by us to other carriers to terminate calls from our customers and certain taxes and fees.
Telecommunication cost recoveries are an ongoing operational activity. We typically record a significant amount of credits each quarter. In addition to typical activity, and as described in Notes 6 to the condensed consolidated financial statements, we recognized benefits to cost of revenue of approximately $0.6 million in the three months ended March 31, 2008 relating to negotiating settlements that were less than the recorded liabilities. This settlement related to the Georgia Rate Remand accrual that spanned a long period of time.
Selling, General and Administrative and Other Operating Expenses (Dollar amounts in thousands)
For the Three Months Ended
March 31, 2009 March 31, 2008 Change from Previous Period
% of % of
Dollars Revenue Dollars Revenue Dollars Percent
Selling, general and administrative
(exclusive of depreciation and
amortization):
Salaries, wages and benefits
(excluding share-based
. . .
|
|
|